Delhi HC issues notice in plea seeking advertising norms for crypto exchanges
NEW DELHI: The Delhi high court on Wednesday issued notice to the Centre, Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) and others in a plea seeking setting up of guidelines or rules for domestic crypto currency exchanges advertising on televisions, as per a report in legal portal Bar and Bench.
A bench of justices DN Patel and Jyoti Singh sought responses from the central government, Sebi, as well as multiple crypto platforms such as Wazir X, CoinDCX and Coinswitch Kuber on the matter. The case will be next heard in August.
Petitioners sought direction to Sebi to issue guidelines mandating disclaimer text covering 80% of a screen, with a slow voice-over, lasting five seconds, against audio-visual advertisements run by crypto-asset exchanges.
The plea also sought a stop on audio-visual advertisements till the guidelines are issued, the Bar and Bench report stated.
The plea said crypto assets are inherently riskier and more volatile investment products than traditional shares. Since 2010, advertisements run through audio-visual media for mutual fund products have guidelines put in place. Therefore, similar guidelines for crypto exchanges are the need of the hour.
“Crypto-assets must be given the same treatment as mutual funds are, if not more, to protect the retail investors who are not aware of the inherent characteristics of crypto-assets and their risk profile, especially considering the fact that they are highly dependent upon supply and demand in the market and regularly rise when certain celebrities in the crypto-world make positive remarks and also regularly decline when said celebrities within the crypto-world make negative remarks," the plea said
Advertising industry regulator Advertising standards Council of India (ASCI) said that it was following the development closely.
“This is a very recent notice issued by the Delhi High court and we are in the process of examining the same. If, on examination, we see that ASCI needs to take certain steps and consider fresh guidelines in the interest of consumers, we will work towards the same through collaboration with different stakeholders,” said ASCI’s secretary general Manisha Kapoor.
Ranjana Adhikari, partner at law firm IndusLaw, noted that the approach recommended was not new and finds precedence. Last year, during the pandemic, Adhikari said, when real money gaming advertisements were on a rise, a similar approach was adopted by the information and broadcasting ministry following concerns about advertisements by operators/platforms not conveying financial and other risks associated with such advertisements.
“Crypto currency is not only a risky investment but also requires a sound understanding of the system and the way it functions and how fortunes fluctuate within a matter of days," she added.
Subscribe to Mint Newsletters * Enter a valid email * Thank you for subscribing to our newsletter.
Delhi HC issues notice on plea against Crypto Currency advertisement, seeks standardized disclaimers
By ANI
NEW DELHI: The Delhi High Court on Wednesday issued notices to Centre, SEBI (Securities and Exchange Board of India) and others on a plea seeking direction to take effective steps and issue appropriate guidelines/rules against crypto-asset exchanges in India advertising on national television without adequate standardized disclaimers.
The Division Bench of Justice DN Patel and Justice Jyoti Singh on Wednesday sought responses from the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, SEBI, M/s Wazir X, M/s CoinDCX and M/s Coinswitch Kuber and slated the matter for August.
The Petitioners Ayush Shukla and Vikash Kumar (Practising Lawyers) sought direction to SEBI to issue guidelines mandating that disclaimer text cover 80 per cent of the screen, with a voiceover read in a slow manner and not speed-read, lasting duration of five whole seconds, against audio-visual advertisements run by crypto-asset exchanges.
The petition states that as M/s Wazir X, M/s CoinDCX and M/s Coinswitch Kuber are made a party in the matter as these firms that are directly involved, are established crypto- exchanges currently functioning within the territory of India who run advertisements enticing and drawing retail investors to trade, invest in cryptocurrencies and crypto-assets.
The plea stated that crypto-assets are inherently riskier than traditional equity investment products in the share market, mutual funds as well as all other forms of financial products offering investment opportunities.
It stated that currently, the audio-visual advertisements run by the firms involved in the business have a line of text smaller than the standard size (minimum 10 font size) stating along the lines of “Cryptocurrency is an unregulated digital currency, not a legal tender and subject to market risks”.
It also said that there is no voice-over and in numerous advertisements, the text displayed is less than two seconds, despite the fact that it is an improbable observation that viewers will make when watching the advertisement due to the placing of the text on the screen, the size of the text and the duration of the text (being less than even two seconds in numerous advertisements and in all advertisements being less than five seconds).
The plea stated that Crypto-assets must be given the same treatment as mutual funds are, if not more, to protect the retail investors who are not aware of the inherent characteristics of crypto-assets and their risk profile, especially considering the fact that they are highly dependent upon supply and demand in the market and regularly rise when certain celebrities in the crypto-world make positive remarks and also regularly decline when said celebrities within the crypto-world make negative remarks.
“An ordinary retail investor who views the audio-visual advertisement on television run by the firms involved on a regular basis, as well as on online websites like Youtube, may suffer immense losses as a result of thereof whilst on the other hand; having a disclaimer on screen after the end of the advertisement with voice over in English and Hindi (as may be appropriate) and correct placing and at least 80 per cent coverage in terms of the size on the screen to be viewable and readable by the investor, may instil wisdom of researching and reading up on the risk profiles surrounding crypto-assets prior to investing his hard-earned money in digital assets not understood by him,” stated the plea.
Delhi HC issues notice to Centre seeking standardized disclaimers for cryptocurrency ads
Text Size: A- A+
New Delhi: The Delhi High Court on Wednesday issued notices to Centre, SEBI (Securities and Exchange Board of India) and others on a plea seeking direction to take effective steps and issue appropriate guidelines/rules against crypto-asset exchanges in India advertising on national television without adequate standardized disclaimers.
The Division Bench of Justice DN Patel and Justice Jyoti Singh on Wednesday sought responses from the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, SEBI, M/s Wazir X, M/s CoinDCX and M/s Coinswitch Kuber and slated the matter for August.
The Petitioners Ayush Shukla and Vikash Kumar (Practising Lawyers) sought direction to SEBI to issue guidelines mandating that disclaimer text cover 80 per cent of the screen, with a voiceover read in a slow manner and not speed-read, lasting duration of five whole seconds, against audio-visual advertisements run by crypto-asset exchanges.
The petition states that as M/s Wazir X, M/s CoinDCX and M/s Coinswitch Kuber are made a party in the matter as these firms that are directly involved, are established crypto- exchanges currently functioning within the territory of India who run advertisements enticing and drawing retail investors to trade, invest in cryptocurrencies and crypto-assets.
The plea stated that crypto-assets are inherently riskier than traditional equity investment products in the share market, mutual funds as well as all other forms of financial products offering investment opportunities.
Also read: What the Crypto crowd doesn’t understand about economics
It stated that currently, the audio-visual advertisements run by the firms involved in the business have a line of text smaller than the standard size (minimum 10 font size) stating along the lines of “Cryptocurrency is an unregulated digital currency, not a legal tender and subject to market risks”.
It also said that there is no voice-over and in numerous advertisements, the text displayed is less than two seconds, despite the fact that it is an improbable observation that viewers will make when watching the advertisement due to the placing of the text on the screen, the size of the text and the duration of the text (being less than even two seconds in numerous advertisements and in all advertisements being less than five seconds).
The plea stated that Crypto-assets must be given the same treatment as mutual funds are, if not more, to protect the retail investors who are not aware of the inherent characteristics of crypto-assets and their risk profile, especially considering the fact that they are highly dependent upon supply and demand in the market and regularly rise when certain celebrities in the crypto-world make positive remarks and also regularly decline when said celebrities within the crypto-world make negative remarks.
“An ordinary retail investor who views the audio-visual advertisement on television run by the firms involved on a regular basis, as well as on online websites like Youtube, may suffer immense losses as a result of thereof whilst on the other hand; having a disclaimer on screen after the end of the advertisement with voice over in English and Hindi (as may be appropriate) and correct placing and at least 80 per cent coverage in terms of the size on the screen to be viewable and readable by the investor, may instil wisdom of researching and reading up on the risk profiles surrounding crypto-assets prior to investing his hard-earned money in digital assets not understood by him,” stated the plea. –PTI
Also read: How the pandemic can help make digital currencies truly global
Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram